Judicial Reasoning
Mostrando 13-20 de 20 artigos, teses e dissertações.
-
13. A NORMATIVE THEORY OF LEGAL PRECEDENT: THE FORCE OF THE LEGAL DECISIONS IN JURISTIC ARGUMENTATION / UMA TEORIA NORMATIVA DO PRECEDENTE JUDICIAL: O PESO DA JURISPRUDÊNCIA NA ARGUMENTAÇÃO JURÍDICA
Following precedents is a requirement of human practical rationality. In law,arguments from precedents are present in all legal cultures and constitute one of the most important sources of legal norms and decisions. Here I argue in favour of a universal method to interpret and apply judge-made rules. This method is supported by discourse theory, which provid
Publicado em: 2007
-
14. O uso ciativo dos paradoxos do direito na aplicação de princípios constitucionais : abertura, autoritarismo e pragmatismo na jurisdição constitucional brasileira
The main purpose of this dissertation is to explore the paradoxical structure of constitutional principles as a mean to observe some risks in their enforcement by the Brazilian Federal Supreme Court. More specifically, the risks of an authoritarian and a pragmatic justification of decisions that enforce especially the principle of proportionality, a principl
Publicado em: 2007
-
15. O MODELO DEDUTIVO NA TEORIA DO RACIOCÍNIO JURÍDICO DE NEIL MACCORMICK / THE DEDUCTIVE MODEL IN NEIL MACCORMICK S THEORY OF LEGAL REASONING
Em 1978, Neil MacCormick publica o livro Legal Reasoning and Legal Theory com o principal objetivo de construir uma teoria do raciocínio jurídico (legal reasoning) descritiva e normativa que fosse compatível com o positivismo jurídico de H. L. A. Hart. O método utilizado para apresentar a teoria parte da reconstrução racional de casos concretos pré-
Publicado em: 2006
-
16. Paradigmas de racionalidade e as desicões do STF nas questões relativas à base de cálculo do imposto de renda - pessoa jurídica
This doctoral dissertation aims at checking if the Brazilian Supreme Court uses recurrent paradigms, determined from a specific and defined nucleolus of intelligibility, when judging parts involved in quantifying the tax base of the income tax for legal person. The Constitution through the concept of income, establishes limits to the taxing power which must
Publicado em: 2006
-
17. Civil inquiry / Inquérito Civil
O civil inquiry is the citizens device to protect their natural collective and common individual rights enabling the Public Prosecution Service to properly and accurately accomplish its duties not only with regards to the right to file a suit but also in connection with the dispatch of recommendations as well as the signing of agreements of behavior regulati
Publicado em: 2005
-
18. Duplo grau de jurisdição: compreensão constitucional do princípio e análise de tema sob a perspectiva das reformas introduzidas no código de processo civil pela Lei 10352/01 / Principle of the appellate jurisdiction
This paper deals with the principle of the appellate jurisdiction, and attempts to construe it from the perspective of the 1988 Federal Constitution, offering as well a critique of recent changes introduced in the Procedural Civil Law Code by statute number 10.352 of December 26th, 2001, specially the ones made in articles 475 and 515. The reason for the cho
Publicado em: 2005
-
19. Mythical Judicial Rulings of Higher Brazilian Courts / O mito da prestaÃÃo jurisdicional pelos tribunais superiores brasileiros
âMythsâ can play contradictory historical/sociological roles in society, justifying, shadowing or hiding reality. Scientific knowledge requires âmethodâ. From Plato/Aristotle man brought Logic/Rhetoric, changed them, made additions and experiments with Bacon, Locke and Hume, reached Descartesârationalism, Hegelâs Dialectics, Exegesis School through Kan
Publicado em: 2004
-
20. The problem of reasonableness and the judicial matter / O problema da razoabilidade e a questÃo judicial
In direction to theorectical practical field of normohistoric anthropologic synthesis, rationalism/empirism lay face to face. Also form and substance of different research propositions from experience grounds and so comparative legal studies shows true accidental occurence (âJustice by chanceâ) measured in face of its operatorâs personality and other basi
Publicado em: 2004