Quando o negócio é punir: uma análise etnográfica dos juizados especiais criminais e suas sanções / When it comes to punishment: an ethnographie analysis of the Special Criminal Courts and their sanctions
AUTOR(ES)
Carmen Silvia Fullin
FONTE
IBICT - Instituto Brasileiro de Informação em Ciência e Tecnologia
DATA DE PUBLICAÇÃO
24/02/2012
RESUMO
In dialogue with the national and international contexts of mass imprisonment and criminal justice systems crisis, the Juizados Especiais Criminais (Special Criminal Courts) emerge in Brazil with two scopes: reducing the complexity of minor crimes procedure without stop punishing minor crime even in a soft way. By using horizontal and flexible intervention procedures in which it creates, theoretically, an exchange of interests between criminal justice and conflict parts, favoring a quickly and less painful answer for both parts, this kind of doing justice has been called by bargaining justice. Through ethnography of the Special Criminal Courts of Sao Bernardo do Campo, the research aimed to understand the meanings of punishment mobilized on these bargaining situations. The research revealed that these situations are influenced by the process of affirmation of professional identities in the justice field, especially the prosecutor\ s identity which leadership in these special courts creates a particular dynamic centered on the criminal punishment and not on the conflict mediation. The ethnographic approach of the special courts hearings also made possible verifying the predominance of a system of sanctions attribution characterized substantially by management strategies and also by classical theories of punishment. In this influence play, the forms of punishment that prevail are mainly monetary sanctions and only barely community service. To understand the reasons for the lack of community service application, the research had a second ethnographic moment at the Center of Alternative Punishments and Measures of Sao Bernardo do Campo. Thus, it was possible to verify that the lack of confidence about this kind of punishment is related to the challenges of making the community service mandatory, a reliable punishment for prosecutors and judges. The dissertation concludes that the sanction system mobilized in the bargaining justice, theoretically an alternative justice, keeps a traditional semantic of suffering even in a soft way.
ASSUNTO(S)
alternative punishment community service order dejudicialização juizados especiais criminais penas alternativas prestação de serviços à comunidade pretrial diversion sociologia da punição sociology of punishment special criminal courts
Documentos Relacionados
- Juizados Especiais Criminais e seu déficit teórico
- O PROCEDIMENTO SUMARÍSSIMO DOS JUIZADOS ESPECIAIS CRIMINAIS
- Violência doméstica e Juizados Especiais Criminais: análise a partir do feminismo e do garantismo
- ViolÃncia de gÃnero intrafamiliar nos juizados especiais criminais
- Uma análise fenomenológica dos juizados especiais criminais como resposta à crise do direito e do sistema penal